INDEX OF COLD CASE FILES
January 01, 2013
HELP BRING CLOSURE TO THE FAMILIES OF THESE VICTIMS:
#1 Death of STEVEN LAWRENCE (Wyoming Co / 2012)
#2 Disappearance of JONATHAN SKAGGS (Fayette Co / 1999)
#3 Disappearance of CHERICE GWINN (STEPHENS) (Raleigh Co / 1993)
#4 Murder of EDDIE BROWN (Fayette Co / 1992)
#5 Murder of TAMMY DANIEL (Raleigh Co / 1987)
#6 Murder of CYNTHIA J. MILLER (Raleigh Co / 1981)
#7 Disappearance of SUE FAYE ROOP (Fayette/Raleigh Co - 1979)
#8 Disappearance of MARGARET DODD (Raleigh Co - 1977)
#9 Murder of PATRICIA SUE RICHMOND (Raleigh/Fayette Co / 1973)
DEATH OF STEVEN LAWRENCE Long Branch (Wyoming Co) WV
December 08, 2012
DEATH OF STEVEN LAWRENCE
Long Branch (Wyoming Co) WV
December 8 - 11, 2012
Steven Lawrence was reported missing in Long Branch, WV, on December 8, 2012. Trooper D. G. Pierson and Sgt. R. A. Maddy assisted Lt. R. Brooks of the Wyoming County Sheriff`s Office with the missing person investigation. The Troopers learned that Steven Lawrence was last seen standing at the mouth of Long Branch Hollow beside the telephone boxes at around 10:30 AM on December 8th. On December 11th the body of Steven Lawrence was discovered by a motorist in a ditch adjacent to County Route 6/2, also known as Coal Mountain Road. Lawrence was 35 years of age at the time of his death.
If anyone has any information about the death of Steven Lawrence, please contact Crime Stoppers at 304-255-STOP or leave a tip via this website, or call the Jesse Detachment of the WV State Police 304-682-4717.
Please help the family of Steven Lawrence have closure in his death. Remember, you will be anonymous through any contact with Crime Stoppers, whether by telephone or website tip!!
THE FIRE PIT - DISAPPEARANCE OF JONATHAN SKAGGS Oak Hill (Fayette County) WV
August 15, 1999
DISAPPEARANCE OF JONATHAN SKAGGS
Near Oak Hill (Fayette Co) WV
August 15, 1999
At 12:26 a.m. on Sunday, August 15, 1999, a woman reported that she had observed a man lying in the road near the intersection of Route 61 and Dempsey Branch Road. For 911 dispatchers Bill McGraw and Billy Ray Watts it was the sort of call that came in all too often. It could be someone struck by an automobile, it could be someone seriously injured in a crime, or it could merely be someone too intoxicated to find his way home.
Playing it safe, the 911 agents dispatched General Ambulance Unit 112 and Fayette County Deputy J. M. Feltner to the scene. Upon his arrival at 12:40, Deputy Feltner soon determined that the latter was the case. It was obvious that 24-year-old Jonathan Skaggs had had far too much to drink that night. Skaggs refused medical treatment and the ambulance returned to the station. However, the deputy felt a responsibility to get Skaggs somewhere that he could sleep off the alcohol without being a threat to himself or others. With that in mind, he offered the intoxicated young man a ride.
Skaggs was unwilling to go to either of his parent’s residences. Instead, he requested that Feltner take him to Clint Toney’s house located ½ mile up Dempsey Branch Road from Route 61. According to Skaggs, he was a frequent visitor to the Toney residence and could spend the night there. The officer transported Skaggs to the residence and watched until he had entered the house.
Almost exactly 24 hours later, Tommy Bibb, Jonathan Skagg’s stepfather, contacted Deputy Feltner. Bibb advised the deputy that no one had seen Jonathan since Saturday night and that he and his wife were concerned about his safety. The deputy informed Bibb that he had seen Jonathan the night before and he had been intoxicated but perfectly healthy. However, when Jonathan had still not returned home by Tuesday, Bibb and his wife worried enough to contact the deputy again. Bibb told Deputy Feltner that Jonathan had not picked up his paycheck on Monday, which he had never failed to do before. On August 17, 1999, Jonathan Wesley Skaggs was officially listed as a missing person.
The Sheriff ’s department began retracing Jonathan’s steps on the day before his disappearance. His stepsister, Christina Bibb had dropped the young man off at the home of his father, Gary Skaggs, in the Dempsey Branch area on Saturday, August 14. According to Bibb, Jonathan had left his father’s home to attend a party at the residence of Nicole Thomas. The records indicated that Deputy Feltner transported Jonathan to the residence of Alfred Clinton Toney shortly after midnight on August 15th.
Deputy S. D. Snuffer went to Clinton Toney’s residence on Dempsey Branch road seeking information concerning the whereabouts of Jonathan Skaggs. However, Toney informed Snuffer that he had not seen Jonathan for “quite some time”. This seemed to be a strange answer since the records indicated that Feltner had dropped Skaggs off at the Toney house on Saturday night.
Sheriff Department detectives G. E. Burke and Steve Kessler began conducting an official investigation into the disappearance of Jonathan Skaggs. They began by contacting Nicole Thomas who reportedly hosted a party on the night that Skaggs disappeared. Thomas told officers that Skaggs had joined the party around 11:00 p.m. on August 14th. According to Thomas, Skaggs got involved in an altercation with Shaun Tincher and that was broken up by James Jones. Following the fight, Thomas asked Skaggs to leave the party. She provided the names of other people who were present at the party including Mikele Ann Miller, James Jones, Shaun Tincher, and Samantha Obey. Clinton Toney had dropped by the party briefly but soon returned home.
Mikele Ann Miller told officers that she and Shaun Tincher had left the party together around midnight. They had seen Skaggs lying in the roadway. Afterwards, they left the area and traveled to Ingram Branch. When questioned, Shaun Tincher confirmed the versions offered by Miller and Thomas.
Gradually, the story of the night was unfolded. Skaggs had arrived at the Thomas home around 11:00 PM. He left around midnight following an altercation with Shaun Tincher. At 12:40, he was found lying in the street by Deputy Feltner who dropped him off at the residence of Clint Toney at approximately 1:00 AM. However, at that point the mystery began.
Initially officers theorized that in his intoxicated condition, Jonathan had either fallen over a hill or been struck by a vehicle. Burke and Kessler began conducting a search of the roadway between Route 61 and the Toney residence. During the search, they encountered members of Skaggs family who were also searching the area. However, there was no sign of Skaggs along the roadway.
It was as if the young man disappeared after being dropped off at Clint Toney’s by Deputy Feltner. Officers were familiar with the Toney residence. Clint Toney had been living in the home since the death of his mother the year before. Since that time, the house had gained a reputation as a party house and investigators established that a party had been held at the house the Saturday before. There had also been a party going on at the nearby home of Nicole Thomas. Partygoers traveled back and forth between the two.
Detectives decided to make another visit to Alfred Clinton Toney. This time he admitted that Skaggs had been at his home on the night he disappeared. According to Toney, he had constructed a fire circle near the front door and everyone who came to the party threw items into the fire. Contributions included trash, tires, and wood. The fire pit burned from August 13th to August 15th.
Clinton Toney agreed to take a Computer Voice Analysis Test on 08/19/1999. Chief Deputy Steele detected deception in Toney’s responses to the relevant questions, “Did you kill Johnny Skaggs?” and “Do you know who killed Johnny Skaggs?”
On 08/20/1999, Toney came to the Sheriff’s Office and requested to speak with Detective Burke. He told the detective that he might have burned Skaggs in the fire at his home. He said that later he had removed the ash and debris from the fire, along with other household debris, and disposed of these ashes and trash on his grandmother’s property. While investigating the dumpsite, officers smelled what they believed to be charred human flesh and witnessed what appeared to be bone fragments in the ash. They retreated and requested the assistance of a cadaver dog. Upon arrival, the dog indicated that the ash pile contained human remains. The area was immediately secured as a crime scene. The search went on into the night as deputies used a sifting screen to search the ash piles. The local fire department was summoned to provide portable lighting equipment and the search went on through the night. The evidence was loaded into the Jeep of Corporal C. E. Martin and transported immediately to the office of the Chief Medical Examiner in South Charleston, WV.
A search warrant for Toney’s residence was executed on August 21. Deputies seized several articles from the residence that they believed could help tell the story of the fate of Skaggs. The most chilling clues came from the circular stone fire pit located against the hillside adjacent to the cinder block home. Upon close examination and sifting, officers revealed what appeared to be bone fragments and the same type of metal grommet that had previously been located at the dumpsite. Officers also smelled the same charred flesh odor that had been present at the dumpsite.
The evidence from the fire pit was also transported to the office of the Chief Medical Examiner and turned over to Assistant Medical Examiner Dr. Paul F. Mellen. The evidence was described as “36 bags of extremely burned material, weighing 350 pounds”. From this tide of debris, Mellen sifted out approximately five pounds of assorted remains including two fragments of recognizable human femur with skeletal muscle attached, as well as numerous small bone fragments. He also located a rusted and inoperative revolver mixed with the remains.
At this point, the Medical Examiner could state that a body had been burned in the fire pit but he had no way to determine if the bone fragments belonged to Jonathan Skaggs. DNA samples from the bone fragments were submitted to the Smithsonian Institute for a detailed comparison to family members of Skaggs. In January 2000, the bone fragments were positively identified as those of Jonathan Skaggs.
Deputies began to interview neighbors of Toney. A neighbor stated that she had seen Clint Toney at 6:30 AM on the morning of Sunday, August 15th. Toney told her that he was cleaning up and getting rid of things he didn’t want anymore. He told her that he was burning a chair and an old mattress.
On November 11, 1999, Deputy Kessler received a letter from Dr. Douglas Owsley of the Smithsonian Institute Museum of Natural History. Dr. Owsley had concluded his report on the forensic anthropological examination he and his staff had conducted on the remains found in the fire pit and dumpsite. The report states that the bone assemblage represented that of a single individual with 1331 bone fragments totaling a weight of 1162 grams. All skeletal elements were represented in the remains. The report also confirmed that the remains were those of Jonathan Wesley Skaggs. Although Dr. Owlsey could not determine a cause of death, his report did state that all bone breakage was the result of postmortem damage and that the “high degree of fragmentation reflects intentional effort to cause breakage.” According to the doctor, “the pattern of burning and the extreme breakage reflect deliberate manipulations and fracturing of the remains while being burned.”
Deputies interviewed Clint Toney again. This time Toney stated that after Skaggs left the house, he had eaten and then gone to bed. He later awoke and smelled a terrible odor coming from his fire pit. The smell was so bad that he began vomiting. He also saw something black in the pit. He threw more stuff on top of it and went back to bed. It was not until later that it occurred to Toney that the black object in the fire pit might have been the body of Jonathan Skaggs. Investigators found it difficult to believe Toney’s story that Skaggs may have fallen into the pit accidentally. Based on photos of the crime scene, it was estimated that the interior of the fire pit was no more than 4¾ to 5 feet in diameter. Skaggs was 5’7” tall and his body could not have fit in the pit without being folded or broken. And according to forensic evidence, the body had been intentionally manipulated and broken into small pieces as it was being burned. According to witnesses, there was no fire in the pit as late as 3:30 AM but it was burning by 6:30 AM at which time Toney was awake and actively feeding the fire.
Toney altered his story again on August 5, 2001 during an interview at the Southern Regional Jail. At this time, Toney told West Virginia State Police Sergeant Scott Vanmeter a completely different version of the death of Skaggs. Toney stated that Jason Rinehart, Nicole Thomas, Sean Andrews and several others were at his home when Officer Feltner dropped Jonathan Skaggs off there. He stated that Skaggs was angry at the theft of his liquor and that he went to Nicole Thomas’ house to continue the argument. Toney maintained that he went to bed but was awakened at approximately 4:00 AM by the sounds of people arguing. He said that he looked out his window and saw several people from the Thomas party in his driveway. He said that Skaggs was sitting in the driveway and that the men were kicking and stomping Skaggs. He stated that the group rolled Skaggs in a blue tarp and dragged him into the fire pit. According to Toney, when Skaggs body would not fit into the pit, the group used a shovel to push his legs in and then placed tires and other flammable material on top of him to increase the fire. At that time, Toney stated that the group ran away. According to his statement, Toney returned to his bed and did not arise until the next morning.
Police found many details in this story that did not fit the facts. Witnesses had not witnessed the fire burning until the next morning. The people implicated had been consistent in their versions of events that night while Toney had changed his story several times. The blue tarp had belonged to Clint Toney. Neighbors had witnessed Toney actively feeding the fire the next morning. During the following months, rumors spread like wildfire through the community. Tales of witchcraft and devil worship were fired by tales of Toney attending the party in a Devil’s mask. Toney was supplying drugs to at least one member of the party. And Toney continued to change his story to blame anyone and everyone for Skaggs’ death but himself.
The death of Jonathan Skaggs’ has not been forgotten nor has the investigation been abandoned. Fayette County Sheriff William Laird remains determined to see the murderer of Skaggs brought to justice. For the past eight years, Chief Deputy Steve Kessler and the Fayette County Sheriff’s Department Detective Unit have amassed volumes of testimony as witnesses were questioned repeatedly in the determined effort. Clue by clue, statement by statement, the case will be built until prosecution is assured.
Eight years after the 911 call, only one fact remains indisputable. On a dark August night, the young life of Jonathan Wesley Skaggs was lost in the smoke of a deadly fire pit.
And still no one has been charged. . . WE NEED YOUR HELP TO SOLVE THIS COLD CASE. Crime Stoppers will pay a reward up to $5,000.00 to Tipster who provides sufficient information to lead law enforcement to make an arrest on this case. Furthermore, there is a $20,000.00 reward for information leading to the arrest and conviction of person(s) responsible for any unsolved cold case murder in Fayette County, WV. Eligibility to be determined by the Fayette County Prosecutor`s Office. Contact the Fayette County Sheriff`s Department at 304-574-4216.
Crime Stoppers would like to thank George Bragg and Morgan Bragg of GEM Publications in Beaver, WV, for furnishing this story. To purchase GEM publications of "WV Cold Case Homicides" and "WV Unsolved Murders I" call GEM Publications at 304-256-8400.
DISAPPEARANCE OF CHERICE GWINN STEPHENS (Raleigh County)
September 29, 1993
Cherice Gwinn (Stephens) went missing between September 29th and October 1, 1993. She was not reported missing until September, 1994. At the time of her disappearance, Cherice Gwinn was married to Norman Stephens. The couple resided in a small residence on the Harmon property on Brackenridge Road in the Bolt area of Raleigh County.
At the time of her disappearance, Cherice was a student at The College of WV (Beckley College). She enjoyed fitness and was a member of the L.A. East Gym in Beckley. Prior to her disappearance she worked at Spartan Sporting Goods in Beckley.
Cherice drove a 1993 white Dodge Daytona (pictured). This vehicle disappeared the same time as Cherice. The vehicle mysteriously reappeared a month later. Any additional information relating to the storage or transport of this vehicle during the fall of 1993 is of vital importance.
The last person to have seen Cherice alive was her husband, Norman Stephens. Only weeks after her disappearance, Norman Stephens filed for divorce. The divorce was final on Valentines Day, 1994. Norman Stephens never reported Cherice missing and has never fully cooperated with the police. In the years following her disappearance, Norman Stephens refused to talk to Cherice`s family members despite multiple requests.
At the time of her disappearance, Norman Stephens worked for UPS. Shortly after her disappearance, he moved to Cherry Hill Apartments in the Beaver area of Raleigh County. Additionally, in the years immediately following Cherice`s disappearance, Norman Stephens closely associated with Benjamin Williams, who, like Norman, was a graduate of Independence High School Other associates at the time included Robert Miller (a high school friend who had joined the USAF and was living in Texas and/or North Carolina) and his coworkers from the Beckley UPS.
This case is being investigated as a homicide. If you have ANY information pertaining to the aforementioned facts or circumstances surrounding the disappearance of Cherice Gwinn, even background information that you may not think is important, her family urges you to contact CRIME STOPPERS at 304-255-STOP (7867). The investigating officers are West Virginia State Police F/Sgt. D. L. Bowles at 304-647-7600 and Sgt. G. D. Williams at 304-256-6700.
PLEAE HELP THE GWINN FAMILY HAVE SOME CLOSURE ABOUT THE DISAPPEARANCE OF THEIR DAUGHTER. IF YOUR TIP ABOUT CHERICE GWINN LEADS POLICE TO MAKE AN ARREST, you will receive a minimum cash reward of $1,000.00 and up to $5,000.00 cash reward, depending on how helpful your information is to the solving of the case.
THE MURDER OF EDDIE BROWN - LOSS OF INNOCENCE Kincaid (Fayette County) WV
January 22, 1992
The Loss of Innocence
The Murder of Eddie Brown
January 22, 1992 Kincaid, WV
Few places in the world can equal the sense of community once found in the coal communities of the West Virginia Mountains. In their heydays, they were places where neighbors knew and looked out for each other. So it once was in the twin communities of Page and Kincaid where the 1990’s dawned on citizens struggling to protect the idealistic sense of community that had once played such an important part in their lives.
To a stranger passing through, Page and Kincaid seemed the quintessential small neighborhood. The central features of the community were the churches, the post office, a small store, and the Sunoco station. Several churches in the community still held old-fashioned suppers in their whitewashed wooden buildings where members congregated to strengthen their faith in the face of a changing world. Men still gathered at the Woods Quick Mart to trade hunting stories and share community gossip. Children still waited for the school bus inside Via’s Sunoco Station under the protective eye of Eddie Brown. Perhaps it is only natural that a community reflects the character of its citizens. If there was one citizen in particular who manifested the best of the Kincaid and Page area, it was Dewey Edward “Eddie” Brown. The 72-year old life-long resident of Kincaid was a man whose very presence brought a smile to adults and children alike. At 5 feet 10 inches tall and weighing 250 pounds, Eddie had the physical size to be intimidating but his sweet smile and laughing eyes soon unveiled his warm and gentle heart.
In 1992, Eddie was a familiar sight at Via’s Service Station where he had helped people for the past 14 years. Although he worked 12 to 14 hours a day, it was generally assumed that he really didn’t need the money. Eddie lived simply in the family home on Camp Branch Road with his younger sister, Ola. And everyone who Dewey Edward Brown knew Eddie was aware that he always carried money in his right shirt pocket. This was common knowledge, not because Eddie bragged about it, but because people knew that if they went to Eddie for help, he was always willing to pull the money out for a loan or a gift toward gas
Eddie didn’t keep working at the service station because he was an automobile enthusiast. He did not own a car. Eddie kept working for one personal reason - he wanted to be there if anyone needed him. More than anything – Eddie wanted to help people. Kincaid children grew up knowing he could always be counted on to slip them a candy bar if they didn’t have the money. As they grew to adulthood, they knew the same was true for gas or grocery money for the family. For the community of Kincaid, Eddie was a symbol of the type of kindness and trusting innocence that has made small town America a beloved memory.
As the decade of 1980`s drew to an end, the way of life was changing in Page and Kincaid, but no one could have predicted just how bad it would get. Unemployment was up. Property values declined and a new breed of resident began to emerge. Run-down campers were brought in and parked in the hollow near Camp Branch Road. Neighbors were complaining about the partying, drinking, and drug deals that were going on. Community leaders formed a plan to work with the Sheriff’s Department to set up a Neighborhood Watch Program. During the autumn of 1991, residents were distracted from the glory of the changing colors in the mountains by a rash of burglaries, break-ins and windows being shot-out. Police stepped up patrols in the area and a juvenile believed to be the leader of a gang was arrested. Uneasy but hopeful, the community took comfort in the fact that there had been an arrest and at least no one had been hurt. The men who gathered at the Quick Mart for soft drinks and gossip could only hope that the arrest of the troubled young man would mark the end of the crime spree.
If there was one resident of Kincaid who was not worried, it was probably Eddie Brown, who had literally lived there his entire life. While others left in the pursuit of wealth or happiness, Eddie had found contentment without ever leaving his boyhood home.
On the morning of January 22, 1992 Eddie began his day in the usual way. He wasn’t scheduled to open Via’s Sunoco Station until 6:00 a.m. but he usually had it open by 4:00. When asked about his early day, Eddie explained that the other stations didn’t open until 6:00. What if miners headed to work needed something for their lunch? Where would the children wait for the bus if the station wasn’t open? He liked to open early enough to have it warm and ready when the kids arrived for their wait. So Eddie arose early that morning, out of bed by 1:30 and ate the breakfast Ola prepared for him before embarking on the 1½ mile walk to the Sunoco. He donned a hooded sweat shirt, a hooded jacket, and a baseball cap to protect his face from the chill wind of the winter morning. Eager to begin his day, he collected the two flashlights he always carried on the morning walk and started out.
As soon as Eddie left, Ola prepared to return to her bed. As she walked through the house, for a moment she thought she heard muffled voices outside. Dismissing the idea, she turned out the lights and lay down to return to sleep. Moments afterward, nearby neighbors were roused from sleep momentarily by the sound of barking dogs but soon, they too, returned to slumber. Everyone rested peacefully in the knowledge that no one was out there at this time of night but good old Eddie, headed to work.
Eddie made the walk every morning and except in very bad weather, it was one of the highlights of his day. Sometimes Dick and Clarine Marshall would drive by on their newspaper route and stop to offer him a ride but he usually turned down the offer. Eddie liked the walk. That fateful night, he walked in the darkness through the community he loved, secure in the confidence that no harm would come to him in his hometown. He was on a mission to prepare the station for visits by schoolchildren in need of warmth and candy, or travelers in need of assistance.
The next 30 minutes are where the mystery lies. For sometime in that half hour, a single act of violence brought an end to both the kindness of Eddie Brown and the innocence of his community. No one knows exactly what happened in those 30 minutes – or at least no one who will tell it. The next person to see Eddie was former station owner, Eslie Bills. That morning, Bills was driving down Rt. 61 returning to his home. As he passed the Sunoco station, he saw Eddie unlocking the door. He remembers that Eddie looked up with what Bills later described as a bewildered or “deer in the headlights” look on his face. Thinking that his automobile coming unexpectedly down the road had startled Eddie; Bills traveled on toward home with a slight twinge of regret. Glancing at the clock, he noticed it was 2:39.
The Marshalls regularly traveled through Kincaid at that time of night to deliver the Beckley Post-Herald. They had grown accustomed to seeing the Sunoco station opened on their return journey as Eddie prepared it for the coming day. However, this morning was different. They knew that instantly when they saw the station sitting dark and apparently abandoned. As they came closer, they realized that the door stood open even though the lights were out and the alarm buzzed in the darkness. Concerned that Eddie had been taken ill, the couple pulled onto the lot and approached the station. Clarine was startled when she looked into the station. Inside she saw a man with his face covered in blood. There was so much blood that it took her a moment to realize that it was her old friend, Eddie. Concerned, the couple entered the station and switched on the lights. What they saw amazed them. The station area was covered in blood and so was Eddie. He seemed confused and wandered around the room, holding a brown rag to his head in an attempt to staunch the blood. He didn’t seem to understand how much he was bleeding or how badly he might be injured. He didn’t even seem to hear the buzzing of the burglar alarm in the background. Eddie told Dick that he had fallen on the railroad tracks and did not need to go to the hospital. The Marshalls helped him lower the hood of his jacket and they saw that there was even more blood than they had realized. The double hoods that Eddie wore had caught a lot of the blood from the head wound. Blood had run down his back between the two layers of clothing. Bewildered and unsteady, Eddie allowed Marshall to drive him to Oak Hill Hospital. As soon as his brother, Glen and sister-in-law, Carol Brown got the call they rushed to Oak Hill Hospital to be at his side.
At first, the crime seemed an obvious one. Someone had robbed the service station and attacked the elderly station attendant. Probably just strangers passing through the little community. However, as facts were uncovered, what appeared to be a violent station robbery would turn out to be an attack aimed at Eddie himself.
The first indications of this were in the x-rays taken of his head at Plateau Medical Center. The doctor told Glen Brown that his brother’s skull looked like a “road map” of holes and fractures. Someone had hit Eddie hard and more than once. When forensic experts examined the x-rays, it was determined that 72 year old Eddie had been struck at least four times with a sharp, pointed object that had punctured his skull with each blow.
At the hospital, Eddie’s clothes were turned over to his family. His sister-in-law found that the approximately $500 that he always carried in his right shirt pocket was missing. In his other pocket, Carol found a smaller amount of cash that the assailant had missed, the air gauge he used to check tires, and a pen and paper. Eddie was left-handed and he always kept his money in his right shirt pocket. Whoever had robbed him had apparently gone directly for the right shirt pocket and ignored the left – as if they knew where the money would be. Eddie Brown made his way to this Service Station even though he was dazed and mortally wounded.
When they completed their examination, physicians found other indications that made it seem unlikely that he had been the victim of an attempted robbery at the station. His knees were bruised and gravel was stuck in the material of his trousers. The fact that the blows had been struck from behind made it likely that the gravel and bruising were a result of him falling to his knees violently when the attack occurred. There was no gravel at the station.
The next morning, more evidence would come to light to support the growing suspicion that the attack had been aimed at Eddie personally. Kincaid residents, Reba Sayers and Patty Miavitz, found Eddie’s flashlight lying on the ground about 75 feet from the Brown property – within sight of the house. The flashlight had a cracked lens as if it had struck the ground violently. The Sheriff’s department was called and Officer Everette Steele arrived to take custody of this significant evidence. He knocked on the door and attempted to speak with Ola but she was not home.
Sheriff William Laird assigned Corporal Everette Steele and Deputy Garland Burke to work fulltime investigating the assault of Eddie Brown. Looking at the evidence, Steele became convinced of one fact- Brown had not been attacked during an attempted robbery of the station. There was no evidence of any disturbance at the station other than that caused by Brown himself as he stumbled confused and bleeding in the darkness. The broken flashlight and the gravel in his knees indicated that the attack had occurred near Eddie’s home – over a mile from the station.
Although Eddie regained consciousness, he was never able to relate what had happened to him that night. He had no memory of the attack. Investigators were forced to make their own determinations. Based on the evidence, it appeared that Eddie had made the walk to the station following the attack. Family members were convinced that Eddie had known his assailant. Mr. Brown was a large man in remarkable shape for his age. Although he was known for his kindness, he would have defended himself if he had seen the blow coming. Yet he had no defensive wounds at all. It appeared that someone had struck him from behind in the darkness. Struck him, not once, but four times.
Another question concerned the time frame. Ola had not noticed exactly what time Eddie left that morning but customarily he left between 2:00 AM and 2:30 AM in the morning. Yet Eslie Bills had seen him opening the station at 2:39. It did not seem possible that the wounded, elderly man could have walked the one and one half miles to the station in less than 30 minutes. Had someone given him a ride?
And what of the blouse that Eddie was pressing against his scalp in a vain attempt to staunch the flow of blood? It had been assumed at first that Brown had picked up the nearest scrap of material on hand at the station. However, the station owner was adamant that the blouse had not been there when he cleaned and closed the station on the night before the attack.
Indeed, the blouse looked nothing like a cleaning rag. The blouse was of an unusual design and would fit only a very small woman. The material was silky and would be of little use for cleaning. Had someone given this to Eddie to use as a bandage? Perhaps in a fit of conscience after realizing the extent of his wounds?
For the next 29 days, Eddie lay in the hospital, weak and helpless. The walls of his hospital room were covered with get-well cards from the schoolchildren who loved and respected him. Neighbors visited and called in a never-ending parade. Yet all the love and attention would not be enough to bring him back to them. On February 20, 1992, Eddie slipped away to a kinder world.
For those who remained, the battle was far from over. The Page/Kincaid community responded admirably to the crime against one of its favorite sons. David Wood, owner of Woods Quick Mart, and Tim Hannah, fire chief, began a drive to fund a reward for anyone providing information concerning the murder. Quarters from schoolchildren mixed with donations from their parents poured in and the fund rapidly reached $2000. This would be combined with the $5000 offered by the County if anyone would step forward to help the community put it’s grief to rest.
Eddie’s brothers, Glen and Howard, did their best to keep the case active. Naturally quiet and reserved, the two brothers forced themselves to respond to newspaper interviews and pose for photos by Eddie’s grave. Determined to find justice, they posted reward notices all over the county and contacted authorities regularly. Meanwhile, the situation in Page and Kincaid continued to worsen. Citizens were nervous and fearful. Sales of guns and double chains for doors boomed. Ministers expressed concern that someone would be hurt by mistake. State police Trooper D. D. Baker increased his patrols in the area. Like the deputies, he listened for any clue that might put an end to the mystery.
Rumors poured in as quickly as the reward money. Deputies Steele and Burke were busy tracking down every lead. Community members called regularly with suggestions and ideas. Many suspected the frequent visitors of the party campers near Eddie’s home. Rumor maintained that one of the regulars had departed for Florida shortly after the attack. Determined to follow every lead, the deputies traveled to Florida to interview the suspect. At first, he tried to avoid them but later met with them and offered proof that he was not in the Page area that night. One by one, the clues led nowhere as the trail grew colder.
For Glen and Howard Brown, the quest for justice continues over 15 years later. Their faces bear evidence of kindness and quiet strength so apparent in the memories of their older brother, Eddie. Yet their eyes have lost the trust and innocence that Eddie seemed to carry with him. Eddie’s nephews, Charlie and Glen Jr. carry on the struggle for justice and closure.
Due to interest in the Eddie Brown case, in the Spring of 2007, the Fayette County Commission agreed to increase the reward money for information leading to the arrest and conviction of any person responsible for what is considered an older unsolved murder.
January 22, 1992 was a day of loss for so many. Schoolchildren lost a protector. Ola, Glen and Howard lost a cherished brother. David Wood and Tim Hannah lost a friend. And a whole town lost its innocence on the day someone murdered Eddie Brown.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
On March 19, 2007, Fayette County Sheriff William R. Larid IV and local author George Bragg approached the Fayette County Commission requesting an increase in the standing reward for resolution of any unsolved murder case in Fayette County. Commissioners Wender, Lopez and Eskew wholeheartedly agreed and increased the reward for nformation that leads to prosecution and conviction of any unsolved murder in Fayette County from $5,000 to $20,000. Determination for payment of the award will be made by the Sheriff and the Prosecuting Attorney’s Office.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
WV Law Enforcement Needs Your Help. If you have information concerning the murder of Eddie Brown, please contact the Fayette County Sehriff`s Department at 304-574-4126 or Crime Stoppers at 304-255-STOP (7867) Crime Stoppers will pay a reward up to $5,000.00 to the Tipster who provides information that leads to the arrest of the person(s) who murdered Eddie Brown.
Crime Stoppers would like to thank
George Bragg & Morgan Bragg
for the information and pictures provided in this article.
To contact GEM Publications in Beaver, WV, call 304-256-8400.
MURDER OF TAMMY JEAN DANIEL Stanaford (Raleigh Co) WV
June 02, 1987
MURDER OF TAMMY JEAN DANIEL
June 2, 1987
Tammy Jean Daniel was last seen at her residence at 125 Lindy Street in Stanaford, WV, on June 2, 1987. Her parents had received a call from the Beckley Police Department advising that she was the El Cid Club and needed a ride home. Her parents picked her up at around 3:00 AM and transported her to her mobile home in Stanaford. They walked Tammy to her door, but it was locked. She elected to stay in a tent that was set up in the yard. Her parents left and never saw her again.
Tammy`s parents went back to her home later that morning. There, they spoke with Tammy`s husband. He claimed that he had told Tammy to leave earlier that morning and he didn`t know where she was. They followed up with him once again that same evening and he said that he still hadn`t seen her. On June 6, 1987, Tammy was still missing. Her parents then filed a missing person`s report with the Raleigh County Sheriff`s Office.
Raleigh County Sheriff`s Office Detectives following up on this case gained information that led them to search Tammy and her husband`s mobile home. During the search they found what appeared to be large blood stains in the bedroom area. Detectives questioned Tammy`s husband about the stains, but no explanation was provided. He continued to insist that Tammy was fine when she left their mobile home on June 2, 1987.
To this date, Tammy Daniel has not been seen again and her body has not been found. She has since been ruled as deceased and a death certificate has been issued. This case has never been closed and there have been numerous attempts to locate her body throughout the years following her disappearance.
In March of 2007, information was received that the remains of Tammy Daniel were buried on private property in the Sandlick area of Raleigh County. Detectives searched the property with the help of the WV Medical Examiner`s Office, Kanawha County Sheriff`s Office and a team of Archeologists and Forensic Anthropologists from the Smithsonian Institute in Washing DC. Her remain were not found.
Anyone having information on this case is urged to contact Crime Stoppers at 304-255-STOP (or submit tip via this website) or call the Raleigh County Sheriff`s Office Detective Bureau at 304-255-9300.
MURDER OF CYNTHIA J. MILLER - DEATH DO US PART Beckley (Raleigh County) WV
August 26, 1981
Till Death Do Us Part
The Murder of Cynthia Jane Miller
August 26, 1981
Beckley, Raleigh County, W. Va
It is a tragedy whenever a life is lost. However, the tragedy strikes even deeper when the victim is as full of promise as Cynthia Jane Miller who was brutally murdered on the eve of her wedding day.
Full of Promise In August of 1981, Cynthia Jane Miller appeared to be a woman who had it all. The twenty-seven year old schoolteacher had completed a Bachelor Degree in Education and a Master Degree in Math from Concord College and thoroughly enjoyed her chosen career. At 5’8” tall with shoulder length dark hair, she was a pretty woman who was adored by her friends and family. Her winning personality, warm smile, and good-natured sense of humor made her a favorite with every one whoencountered her.
Although the early 1980’s were a time when many young people her age were experimenting with drugs or alcohol, Cynthia seemed to harbor no such curiosity. She was a deeply religious woman who took her faith seriously and eagerly testified that fact to others. Her most active interest outside her career was her work with the church. Because of her faith, the previous two years had not been easy ones for Cynthia. In 1979, she had made a difficult decision to seek a divorce from her husband, Michael Cole. Although the divorce was friendly and the couple remained friends, Cynthia felt very badly about the failure of the relationship.
However, by 1981, she was finally finding reason to look toward the future with anticipation. She had purchased a home at 103 Miller Street in Beckley from her grandfather. The home was near the Park Junior High where she worked and it was a source of additional income from a basement apartment that she had rented out to another young woman named Terry Boland. Cynthia further supplemented her income by selling Avon.
Cynthia had recently met and fallen in love with Gary O’Neal, a City Policeman in the nearby town of Lester. Gary had moved in with Cynthia but she was never fully comfortable with the arrangement because of her religious convictions. By the summer of 1981, Gary and Cynthia had decided to make the ultimate commitment through marriage. To save the confusion of explaining the name change to her students in the middle of the year, Cynthia wanted to get married before school started. .
Excited and Happy The wedding date was set for Friday, August 27, 1981. Because they both had been married before, the couple decided against a formal wedding ceremony. Instead, they would say their vows at the Lester City Hall where Gary worked. That Thursday was a busy one as Cynthia and Gary both worked to finalize the arrangements for the wedding. They were both nervous because they had set wedding dates before but Cynthia backed out. She was concerned that their differences would be too great for the relationship to work. She had remarked to friends that she was concerned because they often argued.
However, this time the couple was determined to go through with it. They were both convinced that their love was greater than their differences. To make the ceremony special, Gary acquired two dozen long stem roses that he planned to present to his bride to carry during the ceremony. He entrusted the roses to City Hall employee Beverly Snuffer who put them in a cool place so the blooms would last until the ceremony. However, the bride would never see her bouquet. Her next flowers would be those in a funeral wreath for Cynthia would not live to see her wedding day.
Cynthia spent the day tying up loose ends on her two jobs so that she could relax over her wedding weekend. Early that morning, she traveled to Park Junior High School to put the finishing touches on painting her desk in preparation for the upcoming school year. She finished by noon and was on time for a doctor’s appointment that afternoon. Following her doctor’s appointment, she returned home and worked at straightening the house until almost 4:00 p.m. However, it was too important a day to remain occupied with mundane housekeeping chores. She was excited about her wedding the next day and wanted to share that excitement with her loved ones.
With that in mind, she visited her father at his job at the Montgomery Ward Warehouse in Mabscott. She spent about an hour chatting with her father about the wedding plans. Before she left, she asked his help with some repairs to the garage door of her home. After work, her father traveled to the house and repaired the door. At 6:30 he left after promising yet again to be on time for the wedding the next morning.
Cynthia went to work sorting out her Avon orders. She did not want any chores to distract her from her first weekend as a newlywed. Gary O’Neal also arrived home shortly after 7:00 p.m. After being home for about an hour, he decided to visit his father in Princeton. The groom was also excited about the upcoming wedding and eager to discuss it with his family. Cynthia expressed an interest in going with him and then reconsidered. She really wanted to get her Avon orders out of the way before the wedding. Gary left around 8:20 and told Cynthia to expect him home at 11:30.
Terry Boland, who lived in the basement apartment, was visiting her parents that evening but she returned home around 8:30. When Terry arrived home, the gate was closed and the dog was running loose. As Boland opened the gate, Cynthia called out and asked her to leave the gate open so that she could bring the dog in. When Terry tried the door, she had a problem with her keys so she asked Cynthia to open the door for her. Cynthia was in a good mood and full of excitement concerning her upcoming wedding. The bride told her that Gary had gone to Princeton to visit his father. Around 9:00, Boland took a load of laundry into the washroom she shared with Cynthia and Gary. However, she found that her landlady already had a load of clothes in the dryer that still had a while to dry. Terry decided to go on to bed and wash her clothes in the morning. After she lay down, Terry heard footsteps as Cynthia returned to the laundry room to check the dryer. Apparently, the school teacher put a load of clothes in the basement washer and returned to work on her Avon orders because she telephoned her Avon manager around 9:00 to discuss some problems with the orders. The two ladies chatted for about 30 minutes. The Avon manager sincerely liked the young teacher and that night Cynthia was especially bubbly and full of excitement about her upcoming wedding. By the time the two friends ended their conversation, it was around 9:20. Gary tried to call Cynthia around 9:30 to let her know that he would be late returning home but the telephone rang on unanswered. He also tried her mother’s house and was told that she had probably left to deliver her Avon orders.
Meanwhile, Beckley City Police received an anonymous telephone call reporting that shots or firecrackers had been heard on E Street at the top of the hill toward the Fayette Street side, near the Miller residence. In her basement apartment, Terry Boland slept undisturbed.
Gruesome Homecoming At 11:35, Terry was awoken by a telephone call from her father. His car had broken down and he asked Terry to come and give him a ride. Terry quickly dressed and left, not returning until almost 1:00 a.m.
Gary O’Neal was becoming frantic with worry about his fiancée. He had tried repeatedly throughout the evening to reach her. When she did not answer the telephone by 11:35, his concern deepened. Knowing that she expected him home by 11:30, it was unlike her to be gone at that time. He kept trying to telephone her with no success. He was confused that his bride would disappear without warning and stay out so late on the night before their wedding. By midnight, his worry had overcome him and he left his father’s house to return home. In this time before cell phones, he was forced to stop several times along the way to try the telephone again. Gary was relieved when he arrived home to see Cynthia’s car in the driveway. He assumed that she had been gone and had just returned home. However, one thing was out of the ordinary. Cynthia always left the porch light on for him if he was gone at night and this time the porch was shrouded in darkness. He had to strike his lighter to find the door key.
As Gary O’Neal turned his key in the lock that night, he had no way of knowing that he was transcending his role in life from police officer to victim. For when he opened the door, he saw his bride lying on the floor before him.
The thought that his bride had been murdered was so far out of the realm of possibility that it took O’Neal several moments to accept it. At first, he thought that perhaps she was joking. Then that possibly she had broken her vow against drinking to celebrate their wedding and was simply passed out. O’Neal set down the package in his hands and knelt beside Cynthia, putting his hand beneath her head to help turn her over. When he did, he withdrew his hand in horror. For the back of Cynthia’s head was covered in blood. Screaming in panic, he turned her body over and attempted to administer CPR but it was too late. He rushed to the telephone and called 911 requesting an ambulance. He then returned to his fiancée and attempted to revive her or find any trace of a heartbeat.
A series of well-trained reactions went into motion the instant that the 911 call came in to the Emergency Operations Center of the Beckley Police Department. At 12.45, an ambulance was dispatched to the scene followed closely by patrolman M. R. Robinson. Officers and medical technicians were on duty at the house within moments. It was immediately obvious that this was no false alarm. An excited, barefoot Gary O’Neal was waiting to guide them to the victim. When ambulance drivers and police entered the house, they found the body of Cynthia Miller lying about two feet inside the doorway. She was wearing a pair of blue jeans and a t-shirt bearing a computer printout of her and her fiancée and the words, “Summer of ‘81” you & me.
Medical technicians could do nothing to help the young almost bride. Although her body retained the warmth of life, the laughing, loving woman who had been Cynthia Miller was gone forever. The damage to her face was so extreme that officers at first assumed she had been bludgeoned to death. Upon closer investigation, it was determined that she had been shot four times – once in the shoulder, once in the ear, once in the top of her head and once in the throat. It was more than just a murder. It was a brutal slaughter.
UNANSWERED QUESTIONS Investigators began an intense search of the home as soon as the body was removed for transport to the State Medical Examiner’s office. However, nothing was found that could give them any clue as to the identity of the murderer. Nothing in the house appeared disturbed. There were no signs of forced entry and no signs of a struggle. The murderer of Cynthia Miller had committed his grisly handiwork and then disappeared without a trace.
On September 2, Beckley Police Department Lt. Cole and Detective Pack consulted Dr. Jamil Ahmed of Raleigh General Hospital. As County Coroner, Dr. Ahmed had been the first physician to examine the body. Ahmed stated that in his opinion, Cynthia had died at approximately 9:30 p.m. Chief Medical Examiner in Charleston, Irvin Sopher, agreed with Dr. Ahmed that the shooting probably occurred around 9:30 and that Cynthia fell immediately into a coma and then died within 30 minutes of that time.
The autopsy report provided little new information to investigators but they did learn more about the shots that had taken the life of the young woman. Two of the four shots had been contact wounds, which meant that the murderer had placed the gun directly against her head before firing. The other two shots had also been fired within 21 inches of her. These were not shots fired in anger from a distance. This was the work of a coldblooded murderer who fired repeatedly at close range.
The time itself was confusing. Terry Boland, who lived downstairs in the house, stated that she was home until 11:40. She admitted that there was an open vent leading from the upstairs down to her apartment and that she could hear normal conversation upstairs. The only sounds she heard on the night of the murder were the phone ringing once and Cynthia walking around upstairs. Why didn’t she hear the four gunshots at 9:30? To test the question, investigators returned to the home on Miller Ave. and fired several shots at the location of Cynthia’s death with a 25 caliber automatic. Officers in place downstairs in Boland’s apartment agreed that the shots were very loud in the apartment. So loud, in fact, that Boland would probably have heard them even if she were asleep. Yet Boland was at home at 9:30. However, she was gone from 11:40 until about the same time that police arrived. Was it possible that Cynthia was killed later than they believed?
Investigators spent the next few months conducting interviews of everyone who had any connection to the case. Although an enormous file of details was compiled, it did not contain the one clue that would lead to the murderer.
“Overkill” In April 1982, Beckley Chief of Police Thomas Durrett contacted the Behavior Science Unit of the FBI Academy in Quantico, Virginia to request a psychological profile in the homicide case. Officials from the BSU responded within a month but their insights were more disturbing than helpful. Specialist emphasized that they lacked enough information to compile a full profile but they did offer these psychological theories concerning the murderer of Miller:
1. The victim knew her killer very well. 2. The victim had recently rejected her killer. 3. The number of gunshot wounds to the victim’s head is a sign of overkill, as well as anger, on the part of the perpetrator. 4. It was very likely in a case like this that the perpetrator has already been interviewed by police authorities and appeared to be extremely cooperative. 5. The perpetrator would appear to be distraught over the victim’s death. This was not merely role-playing. While he hated the victim at the time of the murder, he also loved her very much.
It has now been over a quarter of a century since the murder of Cynthia Jane Miller. Most of the investigators in her case have retired and tried to put the violence behind them. However, new officers continue to search for answers in the case of the bride that someone loved to death.
Lt. Paul Blume with Beckley City Police Department has continued the investigation into the murder of Cynthia Miller as recently as 2006. Lt. Blume`s number is: 304-255-1715.
Please help bring closure to this case. If you have information about the murder of Cynthia Miller, please call Crime Stoppers at 304-255-STOP or use the SUBMIT A TIP feature below to submit a tip via this web site. You will be assigned a code number.
Many thanks to George Bragg with GEM Publications for this story. To reach GEM Publications and purchase "Cold Case Homicides" you may call GEM Publications at 256-8400 or email email@example.com.
DISAPPEARANCE OF SUE FAYE ROOP
February 12, 1979
FEBUARY 12, 1979
DISAPPEARANCE OF SUE FAYE ROOP
Sue Faye Roop seemed to be preoccupied on the night of February 11, 1979. Before going to bed, she talked with her children about how much she loved them and how important it was that they always remember that. Life had not been kind to the 29-year-old mother of three young children (Suzie 9, Jessica 7 and Raymond, Jr. "Scooter" 2). She had dealt with a bitter divorce from her nine year marriage to Raymond Roop after discovering his affair with her babysitter. Sue had suffered some very unpleasant situations: a serious gash to her head after being run off the road in her automobile, her house burned mysteriously while the children were at their fathers and Sue was spending the night with her sister and Raymond had taken her to court attempting to get a portion of the insurance money. Things had been tough for Sue, as although she had been awarded custody of the children and $400.00 a month child support, it had been a battle to keep her ex-husband current with child support payments.
However, as Valentine`s Day 1979 approached, it seemed as if life held some promise of better days ahead for Sue and the children. Only 5`1" tall and 120 pounds with long sandy colored hair, Sue looked like a child herself. But she was a devoted mother and was determined to better life for herself and her children. They had moved into an apartment over Holstein`s Carry-Out in the rural community of Bentree, WV. She was expecting $3,000.00 from the sale of some property around the first of March. She was confident that the judge would rule in her favor concerning the insurance from her home burning. Sue hoped to use the monies to buy a new home for herself and her children. Sue had also become seriouly involved with Pete Brown. Pete had lived with Sue for the past year, but eager to help her build a new life, he had recently joined the service and planned to send for her and the children after basic training. Pete and Sue exchanged letters almost every day. Pete sent money sometimes to help Sue. Sue believed that the relationship would grow into something permanent. After getting the children off to school each morning, Sue would walk to the Bentree Post Ooffice to mail her letter to Pete and to see if she had a letter from Pete.
Monday, February 12, 1979, seemed like an ordinary day for Sue Roop. The divorced, 29-year old mother of three prepared the girls for school. Scooter had spent the weekend with his father. Sue promised the girls that she would pick up Valentines that day and they would make Valentine boxes that evening.
At approximately 8:30 AM, neighbor Sadie Holstein saw Sue come out of her apartment and get into what was either a blue truck with a camper top or a van. Mrs. Holstein could not see the driver and just figured that someone was giving Sue a ride to the post office since it was so cold and snowy. Mrs. Holstein had no way of knowing that she might be the last person to see Sue Roop alive.
When the children returned home from school they found a note signed "Mommy" telling them "to go to Carol`s." However, Suzie and Jessica did not go to the neighbors that evening, they were confident that their mother would return soon and they were eager to work on the Valentine card boxes. The girls worked on their Valentine boxes. They watched for their mother out the store window. A friend of Sues came and spent the night with them. Suzie and Jessica did not make it to the Valentine Day parties that year. They waited for their mother`s return. To their surprise, their father came. He told them that their mother had left them and put them into his van. Roop later claimed that he had received his federal income tax return and that he had came by to pay her some money toward back child support.
Carol contacted Sue`s sisters to tell them that Sue was missing. Sandy and Elly were immediately concerned because they knew that Sue would never abandon the children. They searched her apartment. Nothing was out of place. Sue`s clothing an purse were untouched. The purse contained a money order that Sue had received from Peter Brown. The only sign of Sue`s leaving was the note on the door.
When Sue did not return by Valentine`s Day, her father, Eugene McMillion filed a Missing Person report with the Gauley Bridge Detachment of the WV State Police. Trooper Belcher talked with Sadi Holstein and other neighbors, but learned nothing new. The ex-husband, Raymond Roop, claimed that he had last seen Sue on February 10th when he picked up their son for the weekend. Sue`s father hired a private investigator, Eric E. Edwards, of Charleston to help with the search for his daughter, however, he developed no leads.
In April, the McMillion family turned over a series of letter to the police that Sue had written to her boyfrind, Pete Brown. The letters indicated some troubling information. At the time of Sue`s disappearance, Raymond Roop was three months behind in child support and Sue was threatening to take him to court. It was obvious from the letters that Sue deeply feared her ex-husband. In the letters Sue also mentioned that someone had forged two checks on her account in large amounts, that she knew who it was and that she was ready to confront them. It seemed as if there were people who might want the young mother to disappear.
Investigators were left with nothing but questions. Who was the driver of the van that picked Sue up that morning? Where was she going that she thought she might not return before the children came home from school? Was it fear that led he to have a talk with her children about how much she loved them the day before she disappeared? Was there a connection between the burning of her home, her recent automobile wreck and her disappearance?
For the next three decades, Raymond Roop seened stuck in a revolving door between freedom and prison. He was tried and convicted of a variety of crimes, incluing second degree murder, breaking & entering, possession of a firearm, drug possession and grand larceny. However, police were ever able to prove any involvement in the disappearance of Sue Roop. Nine years later, Sue`s family had her declared legally dead, but the disappearance of their daughter, sister and mother still haunt the family.
For fourteen years there were no new developments in he disappearance of Sue Roop. Her family never knew the closure that comes from knowing with certaintly that a loved one is dead and will never return. Original investigators moved on to other cases, other jurisdictions or retirement. ears passed and all tht remained for the family of Sue Roop was questions. That would change with the discovery of a body on Bolt Mountai in December of 1993 when Raleigh County Sheriff`s Office Detective Steve Tanner was assigned to the case. As is customary with the discovery of unidentified bodies, Detective Tanner began his attempt to match the skeletal remains and the articles found with it with descriptions from missing persons reports. The more he learned about the body, the more he became convinced that the remains were those of Sue Faye McMillion Roop. The body had been abandoned in a forested area, but had nt been buried deep enough to protect it from exposure or discovery. She Roop had disappeared on February 12th of an extremely cold winter when it would have been extremely difficult to dig a burial hole. In addition, the clothing found with the body indicated a person dressed for cold weather.
Examination by the medical examiner revealed that the body was that of a female, 5`4" in height, approximately 30 - 45 years of age. Sue Roop was 29 years of age and 5`1" at the time of her disappearance. The hip-hugger pants and platform shoes found with the body were indicatove the 1970`s style. Family members recalled that Sue wore a gold ring with a small diamond. The body discovered on Bolt Mountain was found with a gold ing bearing a 1/8 ct diamond. Tanner was convinced that the wath found with the Bolt Mountain body provided one of the strongest links to Sue Roop. The watch was distinctive in that it had a gold face and an undersized silver band. A confidential source had identified the watch as belonging to Roop, but would not make an official statement due to fear of the killer. In an effort to confirm the link, Detective Tanner transfered a photograph of Sue Rooop wearing her watch and the watch from the body to the photographic unit of the FBI, asking if it was possible to determine if it was the same watch tht Sue was wearing. The answer was one that Detective Tanner would hear several times over the next few years - "Results inconclusive." Although FBI examiners indicated that the watches were very similar, the photograph was not clear enough for a positive identification.
The body matched in gender, race, size, age and clothing and jewelry were in the right style, but he had nothing that he could take to court to prove that the body on Bolt Mountain was definitely Sue Roop.
In 1995 Detective Tanner hope that would change due to a new process known as mitochondrial DNA testing. This testing could compare the DNA of the skeletal remains to the DNA of Sue Roop`s mother and daughters to determine whether the body was in fact Sue Roop. Tanner refused to let the issue go unsettled. In 1995, at the urging of Tanner, the Raleigh County Commission approved the $5,000.00 funding for the test. The first tests conducted were inconclusive. Although nothing in the DNA tests eliminated oop as a possibility, there was also not enough evidence to prove that it was her skeleton. In 1996, the skeletal remains were sent to one of theleading DNA specialists in the nation, Dr. Mark Stoneking of Penn State University, for mitochondrial DNA testing. Tanner received yet another disappointing answer: The body on Bolt Mountain matched the DNA of Sue Roop`s family in 25 of 26 points. Dr. Stoneking felt that the mismatch on the one point could be attributed to contamination or other factors. Dr. Stoneking made the following recommendation in his report: If there is sufficient compelling other evidence to support the claim that the remains are those of Sue Roop, then the mtDNA ahalsis should be repeated in an independent sample."
Today, Sheriff Steve Tanner continues his battle to bring closure to the family of Sue Roop and justice to her murderer.
IF YOU HAVE INFORMATIN ABOUT SUE ROOP, PLEASE SUBMIT YOUR INFORMATION TO CRIME STOPPERS AND HELP BRING CLOSURE TO THE FAMILY OF SUE ROOP.
MANY THANKS TO
GEORGE & MELODY BRAGG OF GEM PUBLICATIONS
AND SHERIFF STEVE TANNER
for this story. You may call GEM Publications at 304-256-8400 to buy the book containing this story and the stories of many other unsolved murders in WV: West Virginia Unsolved Murders The cost of the book is 20.00
DISAPPEARANCE OF MARGIE DODD (Raleigh County)
September 07, 1977
THE DISAPPEARANCE OF MARGIE DODD
THE MISSING BANK TELLER
On Wednesday, September 7, 1977, Margaret Dodd left her job at the Cardinal Bank in the Raleigh Mall and headed toward home in Shady Spring in her green, 1977 Chevette. Margie Dodd traveled her usual route home but for some reason that has never been determined, she pulled off the road and onto the parking lot of an Amoco Service Station at Beaver. Another car, which appeared to witnesses to be a dirty, greenish colored Chevelle or Chevrolet Nova, pulled in behind her. It appears that Margie turned off her car and removed the keys from the ignition, took her purse from the seat beside her, stepped out of her car and walked toward the vehicle parked behind her. That is the last definite fact that anyone has been able to establish concerning Margie Dodd on that fateful day.
There was no doubt that Margie Dodd was a victim of violence. The first notice to police was at approximately 8:45 PM when neighboring residents called in to report a screaming woman at the Amoco Service Station at Beaver. John Cole was leaving his mother`s residence when he heard the screams from the service station and saw what appeared to be a man forcing a struggling, screaming woman into a car. After getting the woman into the car, the man grabbed up Margie`s purse from the ground. Articles had spilled out of the purse but he left them lying on the pavement and returned to the car and drove away, heading toward Beckley.
Chances of solving the crime appeared very good. Police were on the scene within fifteen minutes of the abduction and within half an hour they had the name and a good description of the victim. The fact that Margie had approached the car behind her of her own free will made officers theorize that she had known the driver or that someone posing as a police officer had pulled her over and she took her purse intending to show her registration and license. Her husband, Kent Dodd, told police that Margie`s purse had a torn flap and that she always carried it carefully to prevent any articles from falling out. The fact that nothing had spilled out in her automobile implied that she had removed the purse from her car herself before leaving it.
The only witnesses who had seen the assailant were John Cole and his young daughter who had been playing in the yard. John had little more than a short glimpse of the man and could only describe him as a tall, slender male wearing blue jeans and a dark jacket. Seven year old Lori could only tell officers that the man who forced the woman into his car bore a resemblance to her favorite television personality - the Fonz.
For the next six hours, Kent Dodd and five State Troopers rode through the deserted roads of Raleigh County searching for any sign of the abductor`s car. Every possible escape route from the area was checked and every automobile which vaguely resembled the one that Margie was seen being forced into was stopped and the driver questioned. It appeared as if Margie and her abductor(s) had vanished into thin air.
MANY SUSPECTS: The next morning officers began interviewing people who worked at the mall where Cardinal Bank was located, hoping to identify people who had previous contact with her. It proved to be an enormous undertaking as 27-year old Margie had been friendly and outgoing. She had only recently purchased her 1977 Chevette. Until that time, after finishing work at 8:30 PM she had waited at the mall for her husband to give her a ride home upon leaving his employment at Lee Norse Company around 11:30 PM. Margie had regularly passed this time by talking to other people who worked in the stores and theatres in the mall, occasionally joining a friend who worked at Montgomery Wards and wait for Kent at the `Pub` a popular lounge located in the mall. Officers began to question all customers of the bank who had conducted business with Margie at the bank on the day of her abduction. No information proved to be relevant. The only man that witnesses could place as having direct unofficial contact with Margie Dodd on the day of her disappearance was her husband. Kent told officers that he had gone to the mall at 4:30 PM to pick up some money from his wife and do some shopping, leaving the mall at approximately 7:15 PM to return home.
Beckley Police Department Chief of Detectives Frank Pack and State Police Trooper Preston Gooden worked together to coordinately the investigation. Days were spent checking side roads, dead-end routes, logging roads and lovers lanes. Over the next few weeks the officers interviewed over 300 people in hopes of finding the one clue that could point a finger toward the abductor. Every possible avenue that promised leads was pursued. Even the 7-year old girl who had witnessed the abduction was hypnotized; still her description was only of a tall, slim man who looked like the Fonz.
The investigation was complicated by a series of brutal rapes which were occurring in the area. Over a dozen women were raped in the year following the abduction of Margie Dodd. Several of the rapes had been committed in the area surrounding Beaver where she had been abducted as well as at the mall where she worked. Police began an intense questioning of known and suspected sex violators in the area, but no connection could be made between of them and the missing woman. The rapist was eventually arrested and no connection could be made between the rapist and Dodd.
CLUES, CLUES: There were even clues of a supernatural source. Several psychics from Ohio contacted Kent Dodd and the police as well as Margie`s parents, Mr. and Mrs. John Horan of Akron, Ohio. Surprisingly, even thought no connection could be made between the different psychics, they all gave similar information. Officers were impressed by the accuracy of some of the information given by the psychics. Also, an anonymous caller informed police that he had discovered a body while parking with a woman in the area of the 4-H Reservoir. He refused to give his name in order to protect his companion as she was married. Surprisingly, the area named by the anonymous caller closely matched the area described by the various psychics. One psychic even sent a map to police, marked by an X where she believed the body would be found. The mark on the map sat directly on the area of the 4-H Reservoir where they had been directed by the anonymous caller who stated that he had found a body while parked with a married woman. Officers were increasingly impressed by the accuracy of the information given by the psychics, at this point they became involved in another phase of the investigation involving the FBI in Ohio. On September 29, 1977, Margie`s mother was contacted by telephone by a man who stated that Margaret was being held by his brother-in-law in Four Corners, West Virginia, and that he would help rescue her for $15,000.00. The subject continued to call the Horans and an FBI phone tap indicated that the calls were coming from pay phones in Akron, Ohio. In another ransom call, the Horans were told that their daughter was being held by `Joe Bob` in a sleazy motel in Akron. Callers identified themselves as `Joe Bob" and `Jimmy`.
DEADLY MEETING: An FBI agent posing as Margie`s uncle picked up a Black male who had promised to take Margie`s uncle to `Joe Bob` to pay the ransom demand and get Margie. Things went wrong during the trip and the Black male was shot and killed by FBI agents. It was learned that the Black male, James William Hendree, was an ex-convict from Akron, Ohio, on parole. A careful check on Hendree`s activities proved that there was no indication that he had left the Ohio area either recently or at the time of Margie Dodd`s disappearance in September, 1977. Hendree had been bragging to friends and family about `making a big hit` soon. Police theorized that Hendree had gained his knowledge of West Virginia through talking with a former cellmate from Charleston. Apparently he had seen articles in the Akron newspapers featuring Margie`s mother`s pleas for information concerning her daughter. Hendree made an effort to capitalize on the pain of the elderly couple.
`NOBODY CARES ANYMORE" In 1979 two psychics made a trip to Raleigh County in an attempt to find Margie Dodd`s body. Both women stated that the missing woman had appeared to them regularly since her disappearance begging them to lead the police to her body. The two psychics decided to travel to WV after Margie appeared to them crying that `nobody cares anymore.` The psychics maintained that the missing woman had been stabbed but had actually died as a result of a blow to the chest. They wre also convinced that two men had been involved in the murder.
Make no mistake: PEOPLE STILL CARE TODAY - It has been 37 years this month and WE STILL CARE!!
PLEASE DO NOT LET MARGIE`S KILLER(s) go unpunished. What if this were your mother, daughter or sister? Someone knows who killed Margie Dodd. PLEASE, if you have ANY information regarding the kidnapping/murder of Margaret "Margie" Dodd, provide your tip to police or Crime Stoppers. Crime Stoppers is completely ANONYMOUS whether you call in a tip by telephone: 304-255-STOP or on our website clicking on the `submit a tip` below. You will be assigned a code number either by phone or by website. That code number is your name to Crime Stoppers. Your identity will never be known. Maybe you don`t trust leaving a tip by phone or by website - you can write out your information and mail it to: Crime Stoppers, 215 Main Street, Beckley, WV 25801.
THE MURDER OF PATRICIA SUE RICHMOND (Raleigh & Fayette County WV)
November 08, 1973
THE MURDER OF
PATRICIA SUE RICHMOND
Raleigh/Fayette Counties in November, 1973: There was no hint that tragedy was to befall Patricia Richmond on the day that her parents last saw her as the petite, pretty, 20 year-old resident of Shady Spring left their home at approximately 10:30 in the morning on November 8, 1973, after loading her orange Volkswagon with Amway products that she intended to distribute to customers on Old Crow Road before taking her grandmother to the store. Patricia Sue was wearing a blue sweater, white skirt and red scarf.
When Patricia failed to return home that evening, her parents filed a missing person report with the WV State Police. A trail for Patricia was soon established, indicating that she had stopped at Ransom`s Market and the Amoco Gas Station in Beaver. As evidence turned up, the investigation would soon move into Fayette County.
Patricia`s burned Volkswagen was found over a hill near the Concho Trash Dump in Minden. There was one unusual clue found in the car, being a partially scorched gold wedding band with the brand name of Gold Circle. The owner of that wedding band remains a mystery. The most valuable information at that time came from a resident who said that he saw the Volkswagen burning and he did not see anyone around the car, but he did see two Black men walking up the road away from the car. He asked them if anyone was hurt and they replied, "No, that they were the only ones in the car." He had offered the two young men a ride but they refused. Both men were described as young Black males, perhaps 19 or 20. One was wearing army pants and carrying an army jacket and was wearing a square-faced diver`s watch with a wide band. The witness noticed that he was wearing shiny black boots and that the sole of the right boot appeared to be about three to four inches thick but the left boot did not have a built-up sole. He was about 6` tall and slender, medium complexion and stuttered a little when he spoke. The second Black male was described to be only about 5`6" in height and more stocky. He was wearing a black leather cap which appeared to have ear muffs on it and his hair was bushy and stuck out from beneath the cap.
The police now had a burned car and description of the men involved, but no trace of the victim. It was not until November 23rd that the WV State Police received a late night call from the superintendent of Plum Orchard Lake who informed that a body had been found by two raccoon hunters in a wooded area near the lake, approximately fifty yards from the road at the base of an overturned tree. An autopsy revealed that Patricia Sue Richmond had died as a result of two stab wounds to the left chest wall. Several items were found at the scene where the body was discovered: (1) A gold colored button chain with a button attached which bore the imprint of a sailing ship (2) a partial tooth plate, and (3) a long black wig.
On the same morning that the body was discovered, two men reported that they may have seen the victim at the Beckley Shopping Plaza on the day of her disappearance. These two salesmen reported that they had been sitting in a car outside of Murphy`s about 1:30 Thursday afternoon on November 8th when they observed a Black man get into a red colored Volkswagen parked nearby. Inside the car was a young white woman sitting on the passenger side. Although they had seen no use of force of any weapon, something about the scene struck the two men as strange and they continued to watch with interest as the Black man started the car to drive away. He speared to be unfamiliar with the gears on the car and had trouble backing it out of the parking space. One of the salesman thought the girl looked familiar as someone that he had seen around Oak Hill. On impulse, he wrote down the license plate number of the Volkswagen as it passed by and headed north on US 21 toward Mount Hope. They thought little of the incident until hearing about the body of Patricia Sue Richmond being found. They turned the scrap paper with the license plate number over to the police and it turned out to be the license of Richmond`s orange Volkswagen which she had been driving the day she disappeared.
Three men who had been hauling coal on Beury Mountain toward Thurmond on the day of November 8th all told identical stories about seeing an orange Volkswagen coming up the narrow road at a rapid pace. The windows were down in the Volkswagen and all three men noted that there were three people in the vehicle: A Black man was driving, a petite Caucasian woman sat in the middle and a second Black man was in the passenger seat. The description of the female matched that of Patricia Richmond exactly, right down to the long black hair and blue sweater with a red scarf around her hair. The description of the Black males in the vehicle matched exactly the description given by the Minden resident who had seen and talked to two Black males walking away from the burning Volkswagen. More specifically, the driver being a dark-complexioned Black male with a large, long face and bushy/kinky hair, wearing a green jacket that resembled an army jacket. The Black male passenger had a broad face and was wearing a black hat with fur around it and no bill. The search for clues began to concentrate on the Beury Mountain area. Police were searching for any clue that Patricia Richmond had been there, especially looking for a pair of white boots which she had been wearing when last seen, but which were not found with the body.
The case was complicated by the fact that the victim had disappeared from her home in Raleigh County but her body had been found in Fayette County. On November 8th, police could place her on Route 19-21 in the morning, at the Beckley Shopping Mall around 1:30 and on Buery Mountain around 2:00. But from that point, her whereabouts were a mystery until her body was found over two weeks later. There the trail ended and the mystery began. The murderer(s) of Patricia Sue Richmond remain unknown and unpunished.
PLEASE HELP THE FAMILY OF PATRICIA SUE RICHMOND FIND CLOSURE. If you have any information about the murder of Patricia, please call Crime Stoppers at 304-255-STOP and leave a tip at www.crimestoppersofraleighco.org. DO NOT give your name - you are anonymous.